Skip to main content
  • 5 min
  • 22 sources

Granada's San José Minaret and Its Former Mosque

The San José minaret in the Albaicín is an 11th-century Zirid tower, all that remains of the al-Morabitin mosque. How it became a belfry, and what to look for.

San José minaret in Granada: the square 11th-century Zirid stone tower with a Christian brick belfry on top, a surviving piece of the Albaicín's mosque history, in low afternoon light

The Zirid shaft keeps its 11th-century stone; the brick belfry on top is Christian work.

The tower beside the Church of San José in the Albaicín was a minaret before it was a bell tower, and according to Granada city council it is the only minaret known in Spain from before the Almoravids,[1] though Córdoba's cathedral tower also preserves the minaret of Abd al-Rahman III from around 951, much rebuilt.[19] With a cistern, it is all that survives of the al-Morabitin mosque, the old mosque of the hermits.[4] The prayer hall is gone, so for a mosque you can actually visit, head to the Mezquita Mayor instead.
Minaret's century of origin
11th century
Only minaret known in Spain predating the Almoravids, per the council[1]
Date given for consecration
7 Jan 1492
One scholarly account dates the church's consecration; others differ[2]
Declared a monument
June 1931
Historic-Artistic Monument status, gazetted in Madrid[3]

What is left of the al-Morabitin mosque

The surviving parts are the tower and a cistern, and the city council lists nothing else of the mosque that stood here.[4] The city council gives its name as al-Morabitín, or the mosque of the hermits, a University of Granada course text renders it the Mosque of the Marabouts,[17] and in 1885 Rafael Contreras described it as a mosque of the morabitos that kept its sacred cistern, though not one of elegant construction.[5]
The cistern is the aljibe de San José, and it too has come down to the present.[6] A mosque needed water close at hand for washing before prayer, so a cistern is often the surest sign of where one stood; this one belongs to the wider system of Albaicín cisterns.
That leaves you reading a survivor rather than touring a building. The tower carries the dating, the cistern carries the function, and the belfry carries the afterlife. Keep those three layers in mind and an otherwise modest corner of the Albaicín starts to make sense.

How the Zirid tower was built

The tower is a square shaft of stone slabs from La Malahá laid with ashlar blocks.[7] Inside, a stair climbs around a square central pier, as square as the tower itself, lit by small slit openings; the one large opening is a window with a horseshoe arch.[8]
The Alcazaba fortress towers rising from the western end of the Alhambra hill, with Granada's old city below

Explore nearby · Monument

Alcazaba, Granada

Granada's oldest fortress and the military core of the Alhambra, built in 1238. Its Watch Tower delivers panoramic views of the Albaicin and Sierra Nevada.

The face of the wall is not quite what it seems. The real coursing is masked by a false pattern of more regular blocks cut into the surface, a trait of 11th-century building.[9] Fernández-Puertas's study of Granada's Great Mosque makes the same observation about this tower, which it calls Zirid, noting that the joints between the stone slabs are faked with chisel grooves.[10]
From the lane that means a tower dressed to look like finer masonry than it is. You notice it only when low light rakes across the wall, so early morning or late afternoon is the time to stand and look.
Two terms help here. Ashlar is squared, dressed stone laid in even courses, and a horseshoe arch curves past a semicircle before it closes, the profile that marks Islamic building in the Iberian Peninsula. Dressing the wall with false joints suggests the masons cared how a minaret looked from the street, which is its job: it is the part of a mosque that announces itself to the whole quarter.

Zirid, Almoravid and the mosque's name

The city council dates the tower to the 11th century, before the Almoravids,[1] and the scholar Fernández-Puertas, writing in 2004, calls it "el alminar zirí" of San José.[10] That makes it the work of the Zirids, the Berber dynasty that ruled Granada from 1013 to 1090.[18] That puts the tower some three centuries before the Nasrid palaces most visitors climb the hill for, and it is a useful reminder that the Albaicín was a built-up city long before the red fortress above it.
The mosque's name is a separate matter. Al-Morabitín is glossed as "of the hermits" and rendered "Mosque of the Marabouts" in English,[4][17] which says who the mosque was associated with, not who built the tower or when.
The tower also had a twin. The minaret of the Great Mosque of Granada was its sister, a little larger, with a base about 4.50 m per side.[11] San José's shaft is the smaller version of the pair: a plain square tower, one horseshoe-arched window, a few slits to light the stair. Reading the surviving tower closely is the best way to picture its larger sister.
Interior of the Sala de los Abencerrajes Alhambra Granada, a key site in Abencerrajes Granada history, looking up at the octagonal muqarnas honeycomb stalactite ceiling rising above the twelve-sided central marble fountain, shafts of light filtering through high windows, warm stone walls with geometric tile dadoes below carved stucco friezes

Deep dive · Article

Abencerrajes of Granada: the noble clan behind the legend

Abencerrajes of Granada: the noble clan who shaped Nasrid court politics for a century and became legend through a massacre story set in the Alhambra.

Tower, cistern and name give three separate clues, and they do not point to the same moment. The tower is 11th-century stonework, the name describes people rather than a date, and the belfry is Christian. Treat each as its own layer and the apparent contradictions mostly disappear.

From mosque to church: two dates, one belfry

Accounts disagree on when the mosque became the church of San José, partly because they date different acts. The historian Juan Ruiz Jiménez has it consecrated for Christian worship on 7 January 1492, the year of the conquest of Granada, with the 11th-century minaret kept and a new body added for the bells, but his entries give no archival basis for that day.[2] Cardinal Cisneros, by contrast, consecrated El Salvador, the former Albaicín Great Mosque, on 16 December 1499,[22] and the sweeping conversion of Granada's mosques is dated to 5 to 16 January 1500, after the Albaicín Mudéjar revolt that began on 18 December 1499.[12]
Ruiz Jiménez also has San José erected as a parish in 1501, and the present church built in 1525.[20][21] Read 1492, 1500, 1501 and 1525 as dates for different steps (a mosque taken over and dedicated, the wave of conversions, the parish, the new building) rather than rival answers; which of them marks the change depends on the account, and 1492 rests on one author's word.
The German traveller Hieronymus Münzer climbed the tower in 1494 and counted a great number of mosques from its belfry, so it was already described as a belfry two years after the conquest.[13] That says nothing about when the brick body above the shaft was built.
Whatever the date of the conversion, the Zirid shaft was kept and a brick belfry of Christian construction set on top; when exactly is not established.[14] It is why the stone below and the brick above read almost as two different buildings stacked together, and the 11th-century fabric, false joints included, survives beneath the bells.

Seeing the San José tower in the Albaicín today

The tower has been a protected monument since June 1931, when the Church of San José was declared a Historic-Artistic Monument and appeared in the decree published in the Gaceta de Madrid.[3][16] The decree names the church, and the church is what holds the tower.
Treat it as a stop on a longer walk rather than a destination on its own, and pair it with a wander through the carmenes of the Albaicín. Allow ten minutes for the tower itself: it is a short look at a wall, but a rewarding one if you know what to see, and the lanes around it are steep enough that you will want the pause.
  • The horseshoe-arch window and the slit openings cut into the shaft.
  • The false block pattern incised into the stone, best read in raking light.
  • The line where the Zirid stone meets the Christian brick belfry.
  • For a working mosque, the Mezquita Mayor is a separate visit.
If you see only one detail, make it the join between stone and brick: it is the point where Zirid Granada ends and Castilian Granada begins, drawn in a single line across the tower. On a clear afternoon the contrast between pale stone and warm brick is stark, and it is the best argument for lingering a few minutes longer.

Frequently asked questions

What is the history of the San José minaret in Granada?

It is an 11th-century Zirid minaret, the only one known in Spain from before the Almoravids according to Granada's city council.[1] It belonged to the al-Morabitin mosque, which became the church of San José: one account gives 7 January 1492, another places the mass conversion of Granada's mosques in January 1500.[2][12] The brick belfry is Christian work.[14]

Was the Church of San José in Granada a mosque?

Yes. The tower and a cistern are what survive of the old al-Morabitin mosque, and the church took its place.[4]

How old is the minaret of the Church of San José in the Albaicín?

It dates to the 11th century and predates the Almoravids, which makes it Zirid work.[1][10]

What is the aljibe de San José?

It is the cistern of the old mosque, still extant, and the other surviving piece of the al-Morabitin site beside the tower.[6]

Why is the old mosque called al-Morabitin?

The sources gloss it as the mosque of the hermits, and in 1885 Rafael Contreras called it a mosque of the morabitos.[4][5] The name describes who the mosque was associated with, not who built the tower.

When did Granada's mosques become churches?

Accounts differ. Juan Ruiz Jiménez gives 7 January 1492 for San José, with no archival basis in his entries,[2] another dates the wave of conversions to 5 to 16 January 1500,[12] and Hieronymus Münzer already found a belfry on this tower in 1494.[13]

Did the San José minaret have a twin?

Yes, the minaret of the Great Mosque of Granada was its twin, a little larger, with a base of about 4.50 m per side.[11] The story of that mosque is in Granada's lost Great Mosque.

Sources

22 references Show
  1. granada.org (opens in a new tab)

    “El alminar es el único conocido en España anterior a los almorávides.”

  2. historicalsoundscapes.com — Granada (opens in a new tab)

    “fue consagrada al culto cristiano el 7 de enero de 1492, con la advocación de San José. Conserva su alminar del siglo XI, al que se añadió el cuerpo para la instalación de las campanas.”

  3. Wikipedia (opens in a new tab)

    “El 3 de junio de 1931 fue declarada «Monumento Histórico-Artístico», mediante un decreto publicado en la Gaceta de Madrid”

  4. granada.org (opens in a new tab)

    “La actual torre de la parroquia de San José es cuanto subsiste, junto con un aljibe, de una antigua mezquita llamada al-Morabitín o de los ermitaños.”

  5. Wikipedia (opens in a new tab)

    “San José. Fué mezquita de morabitos: conserva el aljibe sagrado y tiene algunos objetos artísticos, aunque no es de elegante construcción.”

  6. historicalsoundscapes.com — Granada (opens in a new tab)

    “el de esta antigua mezquita también ha llegado hasta nuestros días, es el conocido como aljibe de San José.”

  7. granada.org (opens in a new tab)

    “Hecho con lajas de piedra de la Malahá y sillares de piedra.”

  8. granada.org (opens in a new tab)

    “Presenta una gran ventana con arco de herradura y pequeñas saeteras para iluminar el interior de su escalera que sube girando en torno a un machón central cuadrado como la torre.”

  9. granada.org (opens in a new tab)

    “El aparejo real con que está construida la torre, está disimulado por otro fingido y sobretallado de despiece más regular, característico de construcciones del siglo XI.”

  10. revistaseug.ugr.es (opens in a new tab)

    “Igual ocurre en el alminar zirí de la iglesia de San José de Granada (fig. 4).”

  11. revistaseug.ugr.es (opens in a new tab)

    “Era hermana gemela de la de San José, aunque algo mayor”

  12. historicalsoundscapes.com — Granada (opens in a new tab)

    “desembocaron en un meteórico proceso de transformación de las mezquitas de Granada en iglesias cristianas, el cual tuvo lugar entre el 5 y el 16 de enero de 1500.”

  13. historicalsoundscapes.com — Granada (opens in a new tab)

    “Subimos a la torre, y desde su campanario conté un gran número de mezquitas”

  14. granada.org (opens in a new tab)

    “La torre se remata hoy con un cuerpo campanario de ladrillo de construcción cristiana.”

  15. historicalsoundscapes.com — Granada (opens in a new tab)

    “En su jardín vimos un olivo mayor que una encina, que estaba cargado de aceitunas.”

  16. boe.es (opens in a new tab)

    “Iglesia de San José, Granada.”

  17. abierta.ugr.es (opens in a new tab)

    “One was the Mosque of the Marabouts in the Albayzín district, on the site of the church of San José, whose belltower is the original 11th-century minaret, one of the most valuable examples of built heritage from the Zirid period.”

  18. abierta.ugr.es (opens in a new tab)

    “The 77 years of history of the Zirid Taifa (1013-1090) saw a succession of four sultans”

  19. mezquita-catedraldecordoba.es (opens in a new tab)

    “Originally, our current bell tower was preceded by the minaret erected in the times of Cordoba’s first caliph, Abd al-Rahmán III, around 951 A.D.”

  20. historicalsoundscapes.com — Granada (opens in a new tab)

    “La iglesia de San José se erigió en 1501 sobre una antigua mezquita de la que todavía prevalece su alminar que fue transformado en torre de campanas.”

  21. historicalsoundscapes.com — Granada (opens in a new tab)

    “El actual templo se contruyó en 1525.”

  22. historicalsoundscapes.com — Granada (opens in a new tab)

    “Fue consagrada por el cardenal Cisneros en 16 de diciembre de 1499 y en ella se erigió, en 1501, la iglesia del Salvador”