Skip to main content
Written by James Walker
  • 5 min
  • 36 sources

Albuñol's Cave Held Baskets and Sandals 2,000 Years Apart

A 2023 radiocarbon study split the Albuñol cave finds into two eras: three baskets about 9,500 years old, the four dated sandals Neolithic. Where to see them.

Cueva de los Murciélagos Albuñol sandals setting today: esparto grass tussocks on a dry rocky slope above a gorge in southern Spain, low afternoon light, no people

Three dated Albuñol baskets were woven from raw esparto about 9,500 years ago; the four directly dated sandals are Neolithic.

For half a century the baskets and sandals from the Cueva de los Murciélagos near Albuñol were read as one Early Neolithic find, about 7,000 years old.[1] A 2023 radiocarbon study of 14 of the cave's 76 perishable objects showed they belong to two periods, separated by a gap of roughly 2,000 years.[2][3] The cave is on private land and is not a show cave, so the finds to see are in Room 7 of Madrid's Museo Arqueológico Nacional.[4]
Gap between two phases
~2,000 years
OxCal estimate of the hiatus: 1,780 to 2,340 years[3]
Esparto sandals recorded
22 sandals
Two simple and twenty central-core types[21]
Where the finds are shown
Room 7
Museo Arqueológico Nacional, Madrid, permanent exhibition[4]

How a mining find became one Neolithic assemblage

The cave is a chamber 60 m long and 30 m wide, with a 15 m mouth facing east above the Barranco de las Angosturas, about 2 km from Albuñol.[5] A landowner first went in during 1831 for bat guano and to shelter goats, and a vein of galena brought in a mining company in 1857.[6] The lead workers burned much of what they found to keep their boiler running, and Manuel de Góngora y Martínez arrived about ten years later to save the rest.[7]
Among the survivors were baskets holding locks of human hair and opium poppy seeds, and a gold diadem found beside a skeleton.[8] None of these appears in the 2023 study's dating table, which covers only wood, reed and plant-fibre objects among its 76 perishable items.[30] The study adds that only a few of the human remains survive in the museum and that they had not yet been dated.[36] The authors also note that the objects' original positions and associations are unknown, so a dated basket cannot date a burial or what it held.[31] The diadem's age is disputed: Granada's archaeological museum catalogue assigns this type of goldwork to the Chalcolithic.[32]
The earlier dates cover only plant and wood samples. In the 1970s the first radiocarbon tests on a plant-fibre sample and a piece of wood both gave Neolithic dates of 5200 to 4850 cal BCE,[1] and a 1996 round dated two sandals, a coiled basket fragment, wood and one undetermined piece as Neolithic while setting aside an older wood date of 6450 to 6030 cal BCE as an old wood effect.[9] The whole cave then counted as Early Neolithic, a curiosity in Granada's long history and far younger than the deep-time headlines that go to Orce Man, a contested skull fragment from the north of the province.

What the 2023 dates changed

The 2023 study in Science Advances replaced one assemblage with two phases. Fourteen of the 76 perishable objects were radiocarbon dated and the results modelled in a Bayesian chronology, which gave this sequence:[2]
  • Phase 1, Mesolithic hunter-gatherers: it ends around 7480 to 7100 cal BCE, close to 9,500 years ago, after a short life of 0 to 530 years.[10]
  • The gap: 2,340 to 1,780 years, estimated with OxCal at 95% probability.[3]
  • Phase 2, Neolithic farmers: roughly 7,200 to 6,200 years ago, the phase that includes the wooden mallet and the four directly dated sandals.[11][12]
Two sandals had been dated in 1996 and two more were measured in 2023, a simple one and a central-core one. The new results matched the earlier pair, so all four directly dated sandals are Neolithic.[13] The sandals kept their place. Only the three dated simple-twined baskets moved into the earlier, hunter-gatherer phase; other dated baskets stay Neolithic. The dates came out of MUTERMUR, a project led by Francisco Martínez-Sevilla of the Universidad de Alcalá in which 15 researchers from 11 institutions re-examined the museum collections.[14]

The baskets and what they are the oldest of

The baskets are the best-preserved hunter-gatherer basketry in southern Europe,[15] a narrower claim than "Europe's oldest". Three are almost complete, woven by closed simple twining from raw, uncrushed esparto (Stipa tenacissima) and decorated with geometric motifs in dyed fibre, and some include human hair or pigment.[16] Some kept leather pieces for hanging them up, and Martínez-Sevilla called the craftsmanship "very complex".[17]
1066 Granada massacre scene in Jewish history: a mob attacking the Jewish quarter of Nasrid-era Granada at dusk, the Alhambra hill silhouetted in the background, smoke rising over whitewashed rooftops, sombre red and amber tones

Deep dive · Article

1066 Granada Massacre: When the Jewish Golden Age Ended in a Day

The 1066 Granada massacre killed Joseph ha-Nagid and thousands of the city's Jews in a single day, ending three decades of Jewish power under Samuel ha-Nagid.

Older evidence of basketry exists, but it is indirect: clay impressions at Coves de Santa Maira in Alicante date to 12,900 to 10,200 cal BCE. The Albuñol baskets are, in the authors' words, direct evidence of the oldest fibre-based objects made by hunter-gatherers in Iberia and in Europe.[18]
Their survival owes more to geology than to care. The cave has almost no humidity, and wind circulating through the chamber cools and dries the air; the authors say these conditions prevent the proliferation of bacteria.[19] Granada's artisan crafts of today, from taracea marquetry to Fajalauza pottery, are thousands of years younger than these baskets.

The sandals: earliest in European prehistory, with limits

The sandals are the earliest and most diverse set of plant-based footwear documented in the prehistory of Europe,[20] and both qualifiers matter. Footwear made of other materials, or found outside Europe, sits outside the claim. Press versions that say "world's oldest shoes" drop both qualifiers, which the authors keep.
Twenty are central-core sandals and two are simple.[21] In the researchers' reconstruction of the central-core design, a small group of fibres may have passed between the first and second toes to a braid tied around the ankle.[35] Some sandals show clear wear while others seem never to have been used, which suggests that some people were buried in their daily footwear and others in clothing prepared for the grave.[22]
Crushing the leaves is evidenced only in Neolithic material, so the Phase 1 baskets were woven from raw leaf and the sandals from crushed fibre.[23] Younger footwear from elsewhere in Europe shows what the claim is measured against:
  • the leather-and-grass shoe from Areni-1 Cave in Armenia, 3627 to 3377 cal BCE[24]
  • Ötzi's lime-bast-and-leather footwear, 3350 cal BCE[24]
  • bast shoes from Neolithic Germany and Switzerland, 3000 to 2750 cal BCE[24]

Where to see the finds, and why not the cave

The finds are on show in Madrid, not at the cave, which stands on private land. Work there needs authorisation from the Junta de Andalucía's culture department, the municipality and the landowners,[25][34] and the cave is not a show cave with regular visits. Even archaeologist-led excursions with municipal backing cross an exposed ledge in harnesses and helmets, clipped to a safety cable.[26] Where the finds and the cave stand today:

Two caves, one name

The Albuñol cave is on private land, needs official authorisation for any work and is not a show cave with regular visits. The Cueva de los Murciélagos at Zuheros, in Córdoba province, is a different cave with the same name, so a search for tickets will not lead you to these finds.
  • Madrid: Room 7 of the permanent exhibition at the Museo Arqueológico Nacional, with esparto baskets, textile fragments and sandals.[4]
  • Granada: Granada's Archaeological Museum, in the 16th-century Casa de Castril at Carrera del Darro 43; check current opening hours and ask what is on display from Albuñol.[28]
  • Albuñol: the cave itself, on private land and not a show cave.[25]
The Plateresque stone portal of the Casa de Castril on the Carrera del Darro, with carved shell motifs and grotesque heads

Explore nearby · Museum

Museo Arqueológico de Granada

Inside the 1539 Casa de Castril on the Darro. Paleolithic to Nasrid-era finds: Phoenician objects, Roman bronzes, Arab ceramics. €1.50; free for EU citizens.

Granada's share dates from the death of Góngora in 1884: his 1,145-piece collection was donated to the Museo Arqueológico Nacional, and 443 pieces stayed in the city.[27] Fieldwork in the cave in 2022 and 2023 uncovered a Late Neolithic hearth and about 2,000 charred plant remains, mostly naked barley, wheats and legumes,[29] so the sequence the 2023 dates sketched is still being filled in. Written history is a long way off: Roman Iliberis comes thousands of years after the last sandal was buried.

Sources

36 references Show
  1. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “Questions persisted until the 1970s, when the first radiocarbon analysis was carried out on a sample of vegetal fiber and another from wood, both yielding Neolithic dates (5200 to 4850 cal BCE) (32).”

  2. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “We present 14 14C dates for the perishable artifacts (N = 76), situating the assemblage between the Early and Middle Holocene (c. 7500 to 4200 cal BCE).”

  3. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “The chronological gap between the end of phase 1 and the start of phase 2 was estimated at 2340 to 1780 years using OxCal’s Difference command (95% HPD).”

  4. man.es — Nota web cueva de los murcielagos.pdf (opens in a new tab)

    “Entre ellos, destacan varios fragmentos de tejido, cestos y unas sandalias elaboradas en esparto y que pueden verse en la sala 7 de la exposición permanente del museo.”

  5. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “The entrance is 15 m wide, oriented to the east; the cave is 60 m long and 30 m wide, with a drop of about 48 m between the highest and the deepest parts (fig. S1).”

  6. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “The shelter was also used to keep goats until the identification of a vein of galena led to its exploitation by a mining company in 1857.”

  7. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “According to Góngora (33), the materials suffered substantial fragmentation or charring when the lead workers burned them to keep their boiler working.”

  8. man.es — 1 primeros enterramientos (opens in a new tab)

    “conservaban mechones de cabello humano y semillas de adormidera. Ya fueran ajuares personales u ofrendas, algunos de estos objetos son únicos, como la diadema de oro que apareció junto a un esqueleto.”

  9. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “Although another wood sample provided an earlier chronology (6450 to 6030 cal BCE) (37), this was interpreted as due to the “old wood effect” and excluded from the interpretation.”

  10. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “Phase 1 starts in around 7680 to 7360 cal BCE (95% HPD) and ends around 7480 to 7100 (95% HPD). This phase was relatively short at 0 to 530 years (95% HPD) (Table 2).”

  11. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “Phase 2 begins in 5420 to 5070 cal BCE (95% HPD) and ends in 4390 to 4070 cal BCE (95% HPD).”

  12. man.es — Nota web cueva de los murcielagos.pdf (opens in a new tab)

    “otros materiales como un mazo de madera y unas sandalias de esparto, nos sitúa entre 7.200 y 6.200 años antes del presente”

  13. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “analysis of a simple sandal (611) and a central core sandal (603) agrees with the previous analysis of two central core shoes (598 and 609) (37), confirming that they date to the Neolithic period.”

  14. man.es — Mutermur (opens in a new tab)

    “están implicados 15 investigadores pertenecientes a 11 instituciones con el fin de desarrollar un estudio multidisciplinar de todos los restos arqueológicos”

  15. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “The burial site of Cueva de los Murciélagos in southern Iberia, uncovered during 19th-century mining activities, contained the best-preserved hunter-gatherer basketry in southern Europe”

  16. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “being almost complete and decorated with geometric motifs made with dyed fibers (Fig. 2A); some incorporate human hairs or pigments (Fig. 2B).”

  17. livescience.com (opens in a new tab)

    “"Some of the baskets also had leather pieces that were used for hanging them up," Martínez-Sevilla said. "The craftsmanship was very complex."”

  18. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “Our study therefore offers direct evidence of the oldest fiber-based objects made by hunter-gatherer populations in Iberia and in Europe.”

  19. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “The lack of prevailing humidity in the area and the circulation of wind in the cave as it cools and dries prevent the proliferation of bacteria”

  20. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “We also present the earliest and most diverse set of plant-based footwear documented in the prehistory of Europe.”

  21. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “Sandals form an important part of the inventory. Alfaro (29) distinguished two types: simple (N = 2) and central core (N = 20).”

  22. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “Some sandals had clear use marks, while others were apparently never used, suggesting that while some individuals were buried with their daily clothing, others had specific clothing prepared.”

  23. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “It is important to highlight that the physical treatment of crushing the leaves is evidenced only in Neolithic materials, suggesting that this practice was not used in earlier periods.”

  24. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “Other examples of shoes have been recovered in Europe, including one from a pit in the Areni-1 Cave (Armenia, 3627 to 3377 cal BCE). This was made of leather and a large number of grasses (45).”

  25. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “We thank the landowners of Cueva de los Murciélagos, D. Lupiáñez Soto, M. I. Lupiáñez Soto, and P. Lupiáñez Soto, for allowing us to carry out fieldwork at the cave.”

  26. elfaromotril.es (opens in a new tab)

    “Aquí están los arqueólogos con los arneses y los cascos, nos ayudan a ponerlos. Tenemos que pasar por un paso muy peligroso.”

  27. man.es — Man bol 2017 35 030.pdf (opens in a new tab)

    “La colección Góngora sería donada al Museo Arqueológico Nacional, y de las 1145 piezas que la componían quedaron en Granada 443.”

  28. turismo.granada.org (opens in a new tab)

    “It was one of the first archaeological museums to be founded in Spain and was officially inaugurated in 1879 as a result of the efforts of the Monuments Commission”

  29. aranzadi.eus (opens in a new tab)

    “These include the presence of naked barley, naked and hulled wheats and various legumes (broad beans, peas and grass pea).”

  30. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “The perishable artifacts comprise 76 individual objects (table S1) including 10 wooden items (one of these being a composite object involving wood, reed, and vegetal fibers), 1 made of reed, and 65 fiber-based artifacts.”

  31. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “We know only that they were recovered from the floor surface in the inner part of the cave but have no information about the association of the objects or their original positions.”

  32. artsandculture.google.com (opens in a new tab)

    “We do know: that this type of goldsmith`s ware belongs to the Chalcolithic period;”

  33. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “not all the organic remains can be ascribed to these periods”

  34. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “The fieldwork in Cueva de los Murciélagos had all the required permits from the Delegación Territorial de Cultura (Granada), local authorities, and landowners”

  35. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “a small group of fibers emanating from the base of the sole may have been placed between the first and second toes”

  36. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (opens in a new tab)

    “only a few of these human remains have been preserved in the museum and they have not yet been dated”