Skip to main content
Written by James Walker
  • 5 min
  • 23 sources

Is Orce Man Europe's First Human? What the Record Says

Orce Man is a disputed 8 cm skull fragment from northern Granada province. A 2024 study dated the Orce sediments, about 1.3 million years old, not the fossil.

Eroded badlands of the Guadix-Baza basin near Orce in Granada province at golden hour, pale sediment bluffs and an excavation trench at the Venta Micena site where the Orce Man fragment was found

Venta Micena, where an 8 cm cranial fragment was found in 1982; a 2024 model dates its sediments to 1.32 ± 0.07 Ma.

"Europe's first human" is the line that follows Orce Man, a cranial fragment about 8 cm long from the Venta Micena site in Orce, in the Guadix-Baza basin of northern Granada province rather than Granada city.[1][2] The fragment has been argued over for decades, and a 2024 re-dating of the Orce deposits by Lluís Gibert, Gary Scott, Alan Deino and Robert Martin, published in Earth-Science Reviews, fixed the age of the sediments without settling what the bone is.[3][23] The headline bundles two fossils and one dating study, and together they give no single oldest-fossil answer.
Contested skull fragment
8 cm
Venta Micena find attributed to a hominid[1]
Fragment unearthed
1982
Found by three Catalan palaeontologists from Sabadell[4]
Venta Micena layer, 2024
1.32 ± 0.07 Ma
Age of the quarry sediments in the 2024 model[6]

Where the claim comes from: a fragment found in 1982

The claim rests on a single piece of bone. Orce Man is the nickname of a cranial fragment from Venta Micena, found in 1982 by Josep Gibert and two Catalan colleagues from the palaeontology institute in Sabadell, Salvador Moyà-Solà and Jordi Agustí.[4] Its discoverers attributed it to a hominin, and that attribution turned a fossil quarry in southern Spain into a name on the map of human origins.
Orce is a village in the north-east of the Guadix-Baza basin, an intramontane basin in the province of Granada.[2] The distinction matters for planning: this is Granada province, not Granada city, and nothing in it belongs to the Alhambra circuit or the Albaicín.
"Europe's first human" travels well because it fits in a headline. It also folds at least three separate pieces of evidence into one phrase, and they do not support each other equally. A caption that says it is making a claim about identity, another about age and a third about priority, and each needs its own evidence.

What the record says: two fossils, one dating study

The record holds two fossils and one dating study that headlines tend to merge, each with its own date and its own method. Keeping them apart is most of the work in reading any Orce story. The first fossil is the Venta Micena fragment, the Orce Man proper; the second is a hominin tooth from the nearby site of Barranco León; the study is a geological dating of the layers around both.
  • The Venta Micena fragment, an 8 cm cranial piece found in 1982 and attributed by its finders to a hominin.[1][4]
  • A hominin tooth from Barranco León, described in a 2013 study with an ESR range of 1.02 to 1.73 Ma and an estimate of close to 1.4 Ma.[5]
  • The 2024 ages: Venta Micena at 1.32 ± 0.07 Ma, Barranco León-5 at 1.28 ± 0.07 Ma and Fuente Nueva-3 at 1.23 ± 0.06 Ma, dates for sediments rather than for any bone.[6]
The figures differ because the studies differ. The 2013 work combined ESR, palaeomagnetic and biochronological data to reach close to 1.4 Ma, while the 2024 work used a Bayesian age-stratigraphic model that puts Barranco León-5 at 1.28 ± 0.07 Ma.[5][6][10] No source consulted explains the gap between the two methods. Granada's other histories are counted in centuries, the Nasrid dynasty's among them, whereas here the unit is the million years and the 2024 margins run to ± 0.07 Ma.[6]
The Plateresque stone portal of the Casa de Castril on the Carrera del Darro, with carved shell motifs and grotesque heads

Explore nearby · Museum

Museo Arqueológico de Granada

Inside the 1539 Casa de Castril on the Darro. Paleolithic to Nasrid-era finds: Phoenician objects, Roman bronzes, Arab ceramics. €1.50; free for EU citizens.

Earlier published figures were different again. A 2022 review reported Venta Micena at 1.6–1.5 Ma from biochronology and palaeomagnetism, with no conclusive evidence of hominins there,[18] and a review cited 1.43 ± 0.38 Ma for Barranco León-D and 1.19 ± 0.21 Ma for Fuente Nueva 3, from biochronology, magnetostratigraphy and ESR.[19] The 2024 Venta Micena age is younger than the first figure and carries a much narrower margin.
Palaeomagnetic dating reads reversals of Earth's magnetic field recorded in minerals. The reversals have no regular rhythm, but each leaves a mark in the rock, and together they establish time periods rather than exact years.[7] Reading the numbers means reading their margins: the tooth's ESR range spans 710,000 years, from 1.02 to 1.73 Ma, which is why the combined estimate is given as close to 1.4 Ma rather than as a date.

What the record does not support

Neither the tooth nor the 2024 ages settle whether the Orce Man fragment is human. Once cleaning exposed an internal crest on the bone, researchers challenged the original identification and proposed an ancient equine instead, while Josep Gibert went on defending a human attribution.[8] The dispute lasted at least 23 years, until Gibert's death in 2007.[9] The tooth comes from a different site: a 2022 review identifies the Barranco León fossil as a deciduous tooth of Homo sp.,[20] and the 2013 paper calls it a hominin tooth.[5] The argument over the fragment does not transfer to it.
The 2024 team built an Early Pleistocene magnetostratigraphy for Orce, recording four palaeomagnetic boundaries within an 80 m succession of lake and river sediments, and used it to date the fossil quarries.[3] An age for a quarry is not an identification of any bone inside it, so the re-dating changes the fragment's context, not its classification.
What does point to people at Orce is separate evidence from nearby sites. The 2024 team's press release points to thousands of Oldowan stone tools and cut marks on bones at Barranco León and Fuente Nueva 3, which is why it treats early human presence at Orce as established independently of the skull.[11]
Two further claims sit on top of this, and neither is proven. The first is the route: the researchers favour entry through the Strait of Gibraltar, a hypothesis argued from the absence of older evidence along the alternative route.[12] The second is the title: a 2025 Nature paper dates a hominin midface from the Sima del Elefante at Atapuerca to between 1.4 and 1.1 million years ago, a range that overlaps the Orce estimates, so neither site can claim "oldest" outright.[13] The TE9 level at Atapuerca is dated at 1.22 ± 0.16 Ma by cosmogenic nuclides,[21] and Dmanisi in Georgia, at around 1.8 Ma, is the Eurasian reference, with the Caucasus and southern Asia occupied some 0.4 Ma before the first peopling of Europe.[22]

What to check before you go

Orce is a provincial excursion, so confirm access before building a day around it. The Josep Gibert "First Settlers of Europe" Museum in Orce was created in 1985 and holds a collection of pieces from the geological sites of the municipality: Venta Micena, Barranco León and Fuente Nueva.[14] Guided tours are offered to tourists and school groups.[15] Confirm opening arrangements locally with the museum or Orce town hall.
Corral del Veleta cirque in Sierra Nevada at dawn, north-facing rock walls over 300 metres high surrounding the glacial remnant below, snow patches clinging to shadowed scree at 3,100 metres

Deep dive · Article

Corral del Veleta Glacier: Europe's Southernmost Ice

Corral del Veleta held Europe's southernmost glacier — active until 1913 at 37°N. Relict ice and permafrost still cling on in Sierra Nevada, shrinking fast.

For a longer outing, the Great Path of the First Settlers of Europe is a circular route through six municipalities of the Huéscar area, Orce among them, that can be walked, cycled on a mountain bike or driven.[16][17]

Before setting out, check:

  • whether the museum is open on your day and what it charges
  • whether guided visits to the Barranco León and Fuente Nueva excavations are running
  • how you will get there, since Orce is a separate trip from Granada city
For prehistory without leaving town, the Museo Arqueológico de Granada is the nearer stop, while the Roman town of Iliberis and its Council of Elvira marks a far later stretch of the city's own deep history. A much younger prehistoric find, the baskets and sandals from the Albuñol cave, is covered in the 2023 radiocarbon study that split them into two eras.

Frequently asked questions

What is Orce Man?

Orce Man is the nickname of an 8 cm cranial fragment found in 1982 at Venta Micena, near Orce in the Guadix-Baza basin of Granada province.[1][2] Its finders attributed it to a hominin, but researchers later proposed it belongs to an ancient equine, and the 2024 dating of the sediments does not resolve that.[8]

Was the Orce Man fragment human or a horse?

Both readings have been argued. After cleaning revealed an internal crest, researchers proposed an ancient equine, while Josep Gibert defended a human identification until his death in 2007.[8][9] Dating the surrounding sediments does not decide between them.

Is the Barranco León tooth the same fossil as Orce Man?

No. The tooth is a separate hominin fossil from Barranco León, dated by electron spin resonance to between 1.02 and 1.73 Ma and estimated at close to 1.4 Ma in a 2013 study.[5] Orce Man is the cranial fragment from Venta Micena.

How old is Orce Man, and what did the 2024 study date?

The 2024 model puts the Venta Micena quarry at 1.32 ± 0.07 Ma, Barranco León-5 at 1.28 ± 0.07 Ma and Fuente Nueva-3 at 1.23 ± 0.06 Ma.[6] Those are ages for the sediments; they do not state the species of the fragment itself.

Are the Orce Man fossils the oldest humans in Europe?

Not on the evidence alone. A 2025 Nature paper dates a hominin midface from Sima del Elefante at Atapuerca to between 1.4 and 1.1 million years ago, overlapping the Orce estimates.[13] The arrival route through Gibraltar is also a hypothesis.[12]

Can you visit the Orce Man museum from Granada city?

The Josep Gibert "First Settlers of Europe" Museum is in Orce, created in 1985, so it is a trip into the province rather than a city stop.[14] Confirm opening arrangements and any access to the excavation sites locally with the museum or Orce town hall before you go.

Sources

23 references Show
  1. produccioncientifica.ucm.es (opens in a new tab)

    “The Orce Man is a 8 centimetres cranial fragment attributed to a hominid and discovered in the Venta Micena site, in Orce, Granada, Andalusia, southern Spain.”

  2. riuma.uma.es — 3c256fd7 b126 43c5 911a b62fb6562fb8 (opens in a new tab)

    “It is situated in the northeastern sector of the intramontane Guadix-Baza Basin (Granada, Andalusia, southern Spain).”

  3. diposit.ub.edu (opens in a new tab)

    “Here we provide a new Early Pleistocene magnetostratigraphy, recording four paleomagnetic boundaries within 80 m of a fluvio-lacustrine sedimentary succession in Orce, southeastern Spain.”

  4. produccioncientifica.ucm.es (opens in a new tab)

    “The fossil was unearthed in 1982 by three young Catalan palaeontologists, Josep Gibert, Salvador Moyà-Solà i Jordi Agustí, from the Institut de Paleontologia de Sabadell.”

  5. riuma.uma.es — 3c256fd7 b126 43c5 911a b62fb6562fb8 (opens in a new tab)

    “dated between 1.02 and 1.73 Ma (millions of years ago) by Electron Spin Resonance (ESR), which, in combination with paleomagnetic and biochronologic data, is estimated to be close to 1.4 Ma.”

  6. diposit.ub.edu (opens in a new tab)

    “Three sites higher in the stratigraphy, which contain evidence of hominids, occur at 1.32 ± 0.07 Ma (Venta Micena), 1.28 ± 0.07 Ma (Barranco León-5), and 1.23 ± 0.06 Ma (Fuente Nueva-3).”

  7. eurekalert.org (opens in a new tab)

    “These changes do not have a specific periodicity, but they are recorded in the minerals and make it possible to establish time periods from the different magnetic events.”

  8. produccioncientifica.ucm.es (opens in a new tab)

    “The crest seemed to indicate that the fragment was not from a hominid but that it belonged to an ancient equine.”

  9. produccioncientifica.ucm.es (opens in a new tab)

    “This dispute lasted for at least 23 years until 2007 when Gibert died.”

  10. diposit.ub.edu (opens in a new tab)

    “The specific age for each fossil quarry is estimated using a Bayesian age-stratigraphic model with 95% confidence intervals.”

  11. eurekalert.org (opens in a new tab)

    “The subsequent discovery at the nearby sites of Barranco León and Fuente Nueva 3 of two human molar teeth and thousands of Olduvayan lithic tools — one of the first human lithic industries”

  12. eurekalert.org (opens in a new tab)

    “We also defend the hypothesis — adds the researcher — that they arrived from Gibraltar because no older evidence has been found at any other site along the alternative route”

  13. nature.com (opens in a new tab)

    “Here we present most of the midface of a hominin found at the TE7 level of the Sima del Elefante site (Sierra de Atapuerca, Spain), dated to between 1.4 million and 1.1 million years ago.”

  14. geoparquedegranada.com (opens in a new tab)

    “Created in 1985, it houses a complete collection of pieces from the Sites of Geological Interest found in the municipality (Venta Micena, Barranco León and Fuente Nueva).”

  15. geoparquedegranada.com (opens in a new tab)

    “There are guided tours for tourists and school groups, as well as general scientific dissemination activities (“Science in Your Town”).”

  16. en.andalucia.org (opens in a new tab)

    “This circular route goes through six municipalities in the Granada region of Huéscar: Puebla de Don Fadrique, Huéscar, Castril, Castilléjar, Galera and Orce.”

  17. en.andalucia.org (opens in a new tab)

    “Others prefer to do it by mountain bike (in some parts the route will take you on the road) and, finally, you can drive.”

  18. riuma.uma.es — Download (opens in a new tab)

    “a site dated by biochronology and paleomagnetism to 1.6–1.5 Ma with no conclusive evidence on hominin presence”

  19. riuma.uma.es — Download (opens in a new tab)

    “The age of BL-D ( Figures 2C,E ) and FN3 ( Figures 2C,D ) was estimated in 1.43 ± 0.38 and 1.19 ± 0.21 Ma, respectively”

  20. riuma.uma.es — Download (opens in a new tab)

    “a deciduous tooth of Homo sp. in the case of BL.”

  21. riuma.uma.es — Download (opens in a new tab)

    “This species is first recorded in level TE9 (Atapuerca), dated at 1.22 ± 0.16 Ma by cosmogenic nuclides”

  22. riuma.uma.es — Download (opens in a new tab)

    “The oldest settlements in Eurasia (e.g., Dmanisi, ∼1.8 Ma) suggest a scenario in which the Caucasus and southern Asia were occupied ∼0.4 Ma before the first peopling of Europe.”

  23. diposit.ub.edu (opens in a new tab)

    “| dc.relation.ispartof | Earth-Science Reviews, 2024, vol. 256 | |”